I thought I would float the idea, see if anyone was interested. This wouldn't be anything special, just a few people working together to remove some of the cyber threats that are out there.
We would identify, investigate and attempt to take it offline.
I look forward to hearing people’s opinions.
And what do you think will happen when you interfere with an ongoing criminal investigation?
This idea has been floated around from time to time and is nothing new. There have been many individuals who've had nice theories about eliminating threats but are too often blinded to see bigger pictures. For instance... You stumble upon say a site filled with despicable child porn, your initial instincts after wanting to physically hurt the owners is to remove the site... Do you remove it? How? Hack into it? DoS it? By hacking into the site, you're no better than any other malicious hacker period. DoS'ing? Same.
Not only are you no better, but you could be setting yourself up for tampering with an investigation by a law enforcement agency. You don't and can't know whether or not the site is under surveillance. You can't and won't know - unless they arrest you - that you potentially crippled the work of investigators who may have been close to legally arresting a website owner/operator and or closing down a website.
Take a step away from the technological aspects of this for a moment... Place this into another situation: "Hi, I've seen many people get mugged on the street and I was wondering if someone would like to join my group of vigilantes. We decided that we are the judge jury and executioner. Wanna join?
Forget about business plans as there would be little viability in it. There may be a personal moral redemptional reward for you, but at the end of the day you're looking for trouble on both sides of the law. To repeat, you could be jeopardizing an investigation and secondly, if you think some of these spammers and kiddie porn peddlers are Jack-in-the-Box do-nothing'ers, don't think for a minute that some organized crime boss making millions off of spam, etc., won't stop to harm you if found. They will NOT hesitate to pay someone to off you for peanuts.